If music be the food of love, play on... this is Valentine week, but R & B, kwaito, rap and reggae (urban Swaziland's favourites) have been muscled aside on my player by a new CD I just bought: the Byrds live at the Fillmore in 1969 (Sony CK 65910; www.legacyrecordings.com). This recording was released for the first time only a couple of years ago, and I had to order it: it's not the kind of music any store here would stock.
The Byrds are one of my all-time favourite bands, and this 69 line-up produced two studio albums: Dr Byrds and Mr Hyde and The Ballad of Easy Rider. The first of these was, and still is, criminally underrated; the second was described by Billy Altman in The Rolling Stone Record Guide as 'a masterpiece'. Anyway, this band played the Fillmore between the recording of these two albums--just a few days after the release of Dr Byrds. The concert reveals even more clearly what we Byrd-watchers already knew: that the late Byrds' glory and might was Clarence White, and that his accidental death in 1973 was a major loss to music. All of White's strengths are on this album: his use of the string-bender, his drive, fluid lines and pertinent distortion, and above all his musicianship. White played many notes but never random or unthought ones.
But that isn't all that I like about this album and about this band. I rather like this bassist too. I have always though that John York was an ideal replacement for Chris Hillman, the Byrds' original bassist. McGuinn didn't think so, firing York after recording Ballad. That this was a mistake has always been clear to me by comparing Dr Byrds and Ballad to the band's next effort, the double-album Untitled. Until now, people have usually disagreed with me, pointing to Untitled's live sides as evidence of what a great band the 1970's Byrds were. Until now, Untitled's were the only live sides we could listen to. Until now. This Fillmore recording champions my cause--York was always more of a Byrd-sounding bassist than Battin, and this album shows it. The songs that York brought to the band were better than Battin's too.